A “Model of Care” is simply defined as the prevailing method through health services are delivered in a particular geographical setting. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) (2015), healthcare management models provide best practice care and services for individuals or group of persons as they progress through the stages of a health condition, injury or traumatic event. Basically, a model of care ensures people get the right health care service from a functional health facility, experienced and dedicated staff, and at the right time (Manion., 2005). But there are different healthcare management models for every country. And each country designs its peculiar set of arrangements for meeting the three basic goals of a health care system vis-a-vis: (a) keeping the citizens healthy (b) providing quality, cheap and affordable care service for the sick and (c) protecting individuals and households against bankruptcy from exorbitant medical bills. Considering that health care systems tend to follow a general pattern despite the local variations, this study will examine four major traditional models of care (Bidassie et al., 2014; Agarwal et al., 2017).
–The Beveridge Model
Developed in 1948, this traditional model of care was named after William Beveridge—the famous social reformer who is considered the brainchild of UK’s National Health Service (NHS) (Petsoulas et al., 2010). Under this model of care, the government takes responsibility of financing health care for citizens through tax payments—the same way public services agencies such as the military, police and public library are funded. In societies practicing the Beveridge model of care, almost every hospital and clinic is owned by the government and doctors work as government employees. There are also private doctors who collect fees from the government. But wages are fixed and costs of treatments are standardised.
For example, patients in developed economies like Britain never get medical bills from doctors. This explains why similar economic systems usually have low costs per capita because the government—as a sole payer—is in charge of medical services and billing methods used to calculate cost of care rendered in hospitals, clinics or nursing homes. Some examples of countries using the Beveridge model of care of its variations are New Zealand, Spain, Hong Kong and Cuba (Atchison & Bujak., 2001).
A major pitfall of the Beveridge model is its vulnerability to potential risk of overutilization because, without proactive monitoring mechanisms and strict restrictions, free access to health care could permit citizens to demand unnecessary and wasteful healthcare services (Chan., 2009). This oversight leads to higher taxes on the populace and increased expenditure on the government thereby affecting overall development allocations (Saksena et al., 2010). To reduce the vulnerabilities of the Beveridge model of care, many countries have laid-down rules and regulations to curb waste as well as sensitize people on the consequences of anti-government practices. Secondly, the model is also criticised for the possibility of overuse and corrupt practices during national emergency situations such as war or health crisis (e.g. COVID-19) that necessitate increased expenditure while public revenue is on a decline.
–The Bismarck Model
This model of care was named in the memory of Otto von Bismarck (the Prussian Chancellor who invented the welfare state as part of the unification of Germany in the 19th century). The Bismarck model promotes a more decentralized form of healthcare. And notwithstanding its European background, this method of health care delivery has features of the U.S. care model which utilises an insurance system (Escobar et al., 2010). Under the Bismarck model, health insurance firms in the UK (commonly known as ‘sickness funds’) are jointly financed with payroll deductions from employers of labour and their employees. But unlike the American insurance sector, Bismarck-type health insurance plans offer full coverage for everyone and is operated as a not-for-profit organization (Petsoulas et al., 2010; De Weger et al., 2018).
However, Bismarck countries allow establishment of private hospitals and doctors are free to work in private-owned healthcare organizations. Health providers and hospitals are generally private although multiple competing insurers are public Some countries practising the Bismarck model are the U.S., Japan, Germany, Holland, Belgium, Switzerland, France and some South American countries. Evidence-based research shows Japan has more private hospitals than the U.S., and Germany has over 250 separate funds to run its multi-payer Bismarck model. But despite the decentralized nature of Bismarck model, cost control is easily enforced with strict governmental regulations, and this makes the model equally beneficial to patients as its Beveridge counterpart (Boerma., 2006; Currie & Lockett., 2011).
But there’s an erroneous assumption that the Bismarck model covers everyone like the Beveridge care framework. Evidence-based research shows that the Bismarck model does not offer universal health coverage (Roshanghalb et al., 2018). Only verified employees of organizations are eligible for health insurance (Escobar et al., 2010). Thus, the Bismarck model favours workers who contribute meaningfully to the economic development of the practising countries. In this regard, tight cost-control measures from the government and efficient distribution of resources are some of the appealing features (Marchildon & Di Matteo., 2014).
Yet, the Bismarck model of care is widely criticised for neglecting the unemployed, aging or disabled segment who are not privileged to contribute to economic development. The model also allows imbalance between retirees and active workers (Atun et al., 2006).
—The National Health Insurance (NHI) Model
This National Health Insurance system combines features of both Beveridge and Bismarck models because it allows establishment of private hospitals whereas billing and payment methods are controlled by a government-run insurance program funded by the citizens (Escobar et al., 2010). Thus, there’s no need to market care services and healthcare organizations do not exist to make profits. Additionally, hospitals have low cases of denied claims because the universal insurance programs reduce cost of care. Health administration in countries practising the NHI model is also simpler when compared to other models of care. It is worth noting that the balance between private- and public-sector providers gives hospitals and healthcare organizations more freedom without the tiring complication of insurance plans and policies. Some NHI-countries are Taiwan, Canada and South Korea (Starfield et al., 2005a).
Although individual patients tend to have considerable market power to negotiate and reduce cost of drugs and medical services, the NHI model is mainly criticised for delays in treatment caused by long waiting lists. This is considered serious health policy issue in Canada (Hutchison et al., 2011). For example, the Canadian government successfully negotiated minimal reduction of the price of drugs sold at pharmaceutical companies, and the pricing system has attracted huge purchases from American living close to the Canadian border.
–The Out-of-Pocket Model
Only about one-quarter of countries in the world have established fully-functional health care systems—specifically industrialized countries. Although every government has an obligation to provide basic health care for its citizens, evidence-based studies show that political instability, corruption and poverty are some of the major factors militating against the actualization of national health objectives (Roshanghalb et al., 2018). In Nigeria, as well as other developing countries practising the Out-of-Pocket care model, quality medical care is mostly affordable only to the affluent class whereas. In rural regions of Africa, China, India and South America, it is an acceptable trend for hundreds of millions of people to live in pain and penury and with no access to quality healthcare—unless they can afford it (Aiken et al., 2011).
A large number of the poor masses live their whole lives without ever receiving professional medical care. Their only access to health care is probably traditional doctors (herbalists) who—in most cases—offer ineffective remedies to injuries, ailments and diseases. In some low-class urban areas, too, patients sometimes need to pay outrageous bills for diagnosis and/or treatment. If they have no money (or something to barter), they don’t get medical care. Thus, the Out-of-Pocket care model is the most common in less-developed countries/areas with inadequate financial resources or economic structures to establish a strong medical system like the previous three: The Beveridge, Bismarck and NHI models.
The Out-of-Pocket model is mainly driven by income and is vulnerable to exploitation from government-owned and private-sector competitors in health care business.
Generally, the traditional models of care tend to be less personal because doctor-patient relationships are usually hard to build due to the large number of people visiting the physician. This makes patients feel like they are just another number on the waiting list. Third-party interference is another feature of the traditional models of care (particularly the Beveridge, Bismarck and NHI models) because it is common for insurance firms, including the government, to meddle with care services provided by the physician thereby leaving patients at the hands of non-medical professionals (Escobar et al., 2010). The Out-of-Pocket model is also criticised for allowing hidden charges because there’s no standardized costing method. Generally, patients in societies practising the Beveridge, Bismarck and NHI models of care do not often know what they’re paying for, and as a result, many people prefer to pay out-of-pocket, so they seek health care services elsewhere (Marchildon & Di Matteo., 2014).

Leave a Reply