Theories are an integral part of healthcare practice, promotion, and research although it must be noted that the choice of theory in healthcare organization influences performance of medical practitioners and researchers—particularly in the method of data collection and analysis. Therefore, the psychological aspect of organizations should not be neglected as a factor that can motivate employees to innovate. This section of the study examines whether supportive organizations are truly those whose managers empower workers to transform creative ideas into innovative outputs (Arora et al., 2011).
The Leader-Member Exchange (LMX) Theory: Theories of innovation in healthcare management emphasize the correlation between leadership, creativity and innovative behaviour The LMX theory emphasizes a two-way (dyadic) relationship-based approach to management that empowers workers with material resources —including confidential, classified or restricted information. This approach supports information sharing between organizational leaders and followers (Ingerslev., 2016).
Basically, the LMX theory is characterized with a high degree of mutual trust and network building which influence the overall performance of organizations. Proponents of the theory based their logic on evidence-based study that showed workers’ output is determined by how they are treated by their managers. LMX answers questions like: (a) Is your manager acting in your best interest? (b) Is your manager supporting, loyal, caring, and reliable? High quality LMX characterized by leadership support and empowerment in health systems has been linked greater effectiveness in all phases of the innovation process. For example, empirical research conducted with top management personnel in UK hospitals showed that group process—particularly the relationship between managers and their subordinates—was a determinant factor on the level of innovation/creativity applied. But the number of innovative employees showed higher predictability on how radical the innovations would be. Availability of work tools (including ICT and other health technologies) that improves work process did not predict innovation among health care workers This emphasizes the relevance of social capital in healthcare organizations. The results also underscored the importance of relationships, motivation, and collaborative efforts between health administrators and network assets—such as health providers, patients, innovators, academic institutions, researchers, governmental agencies/parastatals, NGOs, industry/professional groups etc (Wisdom et al., 2014; Jacobs., 2015; Weng et al., 2015).
Diffusion of Innovations Theory: In this context, diffusion refers to a noticeable social process (reaction) resulting from people’s knowledge about innovations such as new, evidence-based ways of improving health care delivery (Dearing & Singhal., 2006; Cho et al., 2009). Diffusion involves sharing of information—about an innovation—through certain formal or informal networks over a period of time among individuals and groups within a social system. A major independent variable is the time when innovations are finally adopted. But where complex health organizations are the adopters, the process of adapting innovation requires a reasonable degree of change thereby necessitating assessment by health providers, insurers, researchers, patients Diffusion of innovations theory emphasizes that complementary or complementing innovations are equally important in healthcare systems because systems (or potential adopters) often have options of strategies to adapt. Importantly, failures are acceptable because most innovations in healthcare management are non-disruptive, not disruptive. One of the advantages of the theory is: diffused innovation can also be decelerated when decision is made to adapt new innovations—without abandoning a prior one (Cho et al., 2009; Arora et al., 2011).
Similar to the LMX theory that encourages inclusiveness and collaboration, the diffusion of innovations theory suggests that the pace of diffusion accelerates when there are voluntary adoption decisions in organizations—especially if purpose of the innovation is well communicated and employees are included in the decision-making process. Further, both theories highlight the psychosocial aspect of innovation theories in healthcare management (Cho et al., 2009; Schweitzer et al., 2015). For example, when influential leaders adapt innovative management theories, social systems tend to convert from one normative state (such as cigarettes contain harmful substances) to another (such as smoking is dangerous to health). On the other hand, when opinion leaders disagree with adopters of innovations, perceptions and opinions within systems remain the same. Thus, decisions of adapting disruptive or non-disruptive innovations in healthcare organizations are a mainly reflective of the theoretical leanings embraced by health administrators and governmental agencies—with little influence from physicians and health providers, among others. This scenario, sometimes, allows unworthy innovations to be diffused whereas a bunch of effective innovations are stymied (Zimmerman et al., 2016).
Viewed comprehensively, primary health care (PHC) systems in resource-rich communities that with large concentration of educated, influential personalities have higher chances of acquiring and making use of innovations. This study identified three factors that influence diffusion of innovation vis-a-vis: (a) characteristics of adopters, especially their perception of the opinion leader’s reaction (i.e. social influence) (b) the large socio-political context, including general opinion on the usefulness of the innovations and (c) timing of its introduction (Dearing & Singhal., 2006; Cho et al., 2009; Boushey., 2016).

Leave a Reply