Abstract
Sometimes in health behavior research, purportedly novel theoretical models are offered that may help move thinking about behavior change forward, and may be well-received by clinicians, but over time end up being a subject of continual scientific disconfirmation. The transtheoretical model is one rather popular example. The five stages of change and associated 10 processes of change are well-known (e.g., DiClemente et al., 2008; DiClemente et al., 2004). Yet, the model has been discredited to a large extent by several in the health behavior research community. In the present editorial, we briefly summarize the transtheoretical model, mention its current ongoing popularity, identify the critiques of this model, and suggest how one might best consider the model in future health behavior research and practice.
Keywords
Transtheoretical Model, Stages of Change, Critiques, Needed Research
Brief Description of the Transtheoretical Model
The transtheoretical model proposes that health behavioral changes occur in discrete stages based on intentional decision making and changes in cognition or behavior.
Motivation and readiness to change are the key influences towards progression in the stages of change, which also aid in predicting adherence to health behavior regimens and engagement in the change protocol. Conceptually, there are five stages of change, which are transitional categories of psychological states that occur in a defined order, as one changes their relationship with a health behavior, indicating phases of progress toward a maintenance stage (Herzog, 2008; Norcross et al., 2011). These stages are: precontemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance.
Individuals are assessed on their readiness to move forward in the stages of change (Norcross et al., 2011). The precontemplation stage has been stated to occur when participants indicate being unaware of negative consequences resulting from their problem or sedentary behavior (Norcross et al., 2011). Alternatively, they may be aware of their self-defeating behavior but simply be uninterested in changing their course of behavior. Regarding recovery from drug abuse, individuals in the precontemplation stage do not intend to change their behavior within the subsequent six-month period (Norcross et al., 2011). In some cases, attempts to change one’s behavior lead to discouragement and avoidance (Prochaska & Velicer, 1997b).
Action-oriented program recruitment is said to be the most beneficial during the early stages of the transtheoretical model (Prochaska & Velicer., 1997b). Contem plation occurs once individuals intend to change their behaviors within the next six months. They may become more informed about the positive outcomes of change, but this stage can often be characterized as chronic contemplation when individuals are not motivated enough to make the change (Prochaska & Velicer., 1997b).
The stage of preparation requires a plan of action and is followed by a small progression. Oftentimes, individuals in the preparation stage pursue self-help strategies. It is at this stage where some actions have been initiated but the threshold for effective actions has not been reached (Norcross et al., 2011;
Prochaska & Velicer, 1997b). In some studies, the preparation stage is defined as an intention to change the behavior within the next 30 days.
A drastic change is seen during the action stage, which develops as individuals alter their lifestyles (Norcross et al., 2011). For example, during smoking cessation,
achievement of complete abstinence would be considered as essential to the action stage.
The goal of the action stage is to create sufficient change where health risks are at a minimum (Prochaska & Velicer, 1997b). The last stage is known as maintenance where six months of the criterion end-stage is met. For example, six months of continuous smoking abstinence would define entry into the maintenance stage. The optimal goal is to continue making health-conscious decisions and prevent relapse (Prochaska & Velicer, 1997b). Individuals pass through each stage although relapse and going through cycles of these five stages is possible. Since the mid 1980s relapse has been viewed as a step back in the stages of change and not a separate stage in the cycle (Littell & Girvin, 2002).
While the stages of change describe the discrete categories that a person can be in while improving one’s health behavior, the processes of change have been described as behaviors and cognitions that foster progressive movement through the stages (e.g., Romain et al., 2018). Experiential processes of change (i.e., consciousness raising, dramatic relief, self-reevaluation, environmental reevaluation, and social are thought to be used in the early stages, whereas behavioral processes of change are thought to occur in the later stages of action and maintenance (i.e., self liberation, helping relationships, counter conditioning, reinforcement management, and stimulus control). Summarizing these processes of change: efforts to better understand the behavior needing change, understanding the impact of the behavior on the individual and one’s environment, and social pressures to change (experiential processes) are thought to precede committing to change, enlisting support of others, substituting healthy behavior instead of unhealthy behavior, using rewards to encourage change, and changing the environment to encourage change (behavioral processes). Thus, for example, an emphasis on consciousness-raising during earlier stages is said to elicit heightened emotions (i.e., dramatic relief) leading to grief and fear of consequences brought on by continued drug use or involvement in another problem behavior (Norcross et al., 2011).
Theoretically, consciousness-raising and dramatic relief are hypothesized to “move” a person from a precontemplation state to a contemplation state. During later stages, techniques involving counterconditioning and reinforcement are expected to provide a sense of reward for individuals by practicing relaxation, finding less harmful distractions, and relieving cognitive distortions (Norcross et al., 2011). Reinforcement management and stimulus control are thought of as “processes” that are associated with moving a person from action to maintenance.

Leave a Reply