Chapter 1: The Impossible Task
Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, says the Lord of hosts. — Zechariah 4:6
The Weight You Weren’t Prepared For
There is a moment—usually somewhere between 2:00 and 4:00 in the morning—when the weight of parenting becomes almost unbearable. Perhaps you are awake with a newborn who refuses to be soothed, and the exhaustion feels like it might eventually kill you. Perhaps you are lying awake after a screaming match with your teenager, replaying the venomous words exchanged, and wondering where you went wrong. Perhaps you have just discovered that your child—the one you dedicated to God before the congregation, the one you have taken to church every Sunday since infancy—has been hiding a life you never imagined.
In that moment, the weight presses down: I am responsible for this soul. And I am not enough.
That feeling—that crushing awareness of inadequacy—is not a sign of failure. It is, in fact, the prerequisite for godly parenting. It is the end of self-reliance, and the beginning of something far more sustainable.
We begin this book not with a ten-step program or a set of guarantees, but with a confession: Raising godly children is impossible. It is impossible for you, and it is impossible for me. And if we do not start there—if we begin with the assumption that good methods, consistent discipline, and a solid Christian home will inevitably produce godly children—we are building our parenting on sand.
The task set before us is not merely to raise children who obey, who achieve, or who fit in. The task is to participate—as broken, finite, and sinful parents—in the formation of souls destined for eternity. We are called to be instruments in the hands of the living God to shape hearts that love Him, minds that worship Him, and wills that submit to Him. This is a supernatural task. And supernatural tasks require supernatural power.
This chapter is about laying the foundation. Before we discuss family worship, discipline, technology, or any of the practical matters that will fill the rest of this book, we must settle the question of power. Who does the work of raising godly children? If your answer is anything other than “God, by His Spirit,” you are already carrying a weight you were never meant to bear.
The Illusion of Control
One of the deepest impulses of fallen human nature is the desire for control. We want to be the authors of our own stories, and masters of our own fates. This impulse does not disappear when we become parents; it intensifies. We look at our tiny, helpless infants, and we feel the intoxicating sense that we are shaping a precious life from the ground up. We chose the right sleep training method, the right preschool, the right educational curriculum, the right sports league, and the right church youth group. We curate their environments with the desperate hope that if we get all the inputs correct, the output will be predictable: a godly, successful, well-adjusted adult.
But parenting has a way of humbling that illusion.
It begins early. One child has a temperament that is gentle and compliant; another, born of the same parents, raised in the same home, seems determined to test every boundary. You try the same discipline technique with both; it works beautifully for one and backfires spectacularly for the other. You realize, with a sinking feeling, that you are not the sculptor you thought you were. You are working with living clay that has a will of its own.
This is the first grace of parenting: it exposes our idolatry of control.
The lie we are tempted to believe is that godly children are the product of godly parenting methods. If we just follow the right formula—the right book, the right conference, and the right routine—we can guarantee the outcome. This is moralism dressed up in Christian language. It treats the soul as a machine and parenting as a set of instructions. It leaves no room for mystery, for the sovereignty of God, or for the terrifying and wonderful reality that our children are persons with their own unique relationships with their Creator.
The truth is far more unsettling and far more liberating: You are not in control. You cannot force your child to love God. You cannot legislate a new heart. You cannot say someone else’s prayers for them. You can create an environment, model faithfulness, teach truth, discipline consistently—and your child may still walk the wrong path. Or you can fail in a hundred ways, and your child may still grow into a passionate follower of Jesus. The outcome is not ultimately in your hands.
This is not an excuse for passivity. It is an invitation to humility. It is the recognition that we are stewards, not saviors. We are gardeners, not creators. We plant and water, but God gives the growth (1 Corinthians 3:6-7). And that means the weight of our children’s eternal souls—a weight that would crush us if we truly carried it—belongs to the One who is strong enough to bear it.
Moralism vs. Regeneration: The Crucial Distinction
If we are going to talk about raising godly children, we must first define what we mean. And here, the church has often fallen into a subtle but devastating confusion.
Moralism is the belief that being good—following the rules, behaving properly, and living a decent life—is the essence of Christianity. It is the reduction of faith to a code of conduct. And moralism is the default religion of children raised in Christian homes.
Think about what we celebrate. We beam with pride when our child shares a toy, says “please” and “thank you,” sits still in church, or memorizes a Bible verse. These are good things. But if we are not careful, we communicate to our children—loudly and clearly—that being a Christian means being a nice, well-behaved kid. We train them in external compliance while neglecting the internal transformation that alone constitutes true godliness.
The result is not godliness; it is Pharisaism. Jesus reserved His harshest words for the Pharisees, who were outwardly impeccable and inwardly dead. He called them “whitewashed tombs”—beautiful on the outside, full of death on the inside (Matthew 23:27). A child can be perfectly behaved and have no love for God. A child can win the Bible memory competition and have a heart that is far from Jesus. A child can avoid all the “big sins” and be consumed by pride, self-righteousness, and a deep-seated belief that God owes them something for their goodness.
Moralism produces moral children. It does not produce godly children.
Godliness, in the biblical sense, is not primarily about behavior. Behavior is the fruit of godliness, not its root. Godliness is a heart posture—a disposition of love, trust, and reverence toward God that flows outward into obedience. The godly child is not the one who follows the rules because they fear punishment or crave approval. The godly child is the one who has tasted that the Lord is good (Psalm 34:8) and whose obedience flows from delight.
This kind of heart cannot be manufactured by parenting techniques. It can only be produced by the Holy Spirit through regeneration—the new birth.
Jesus told Nicodemus, a moral man, a religious man, a man who had dedicated his life to obeying God’s law, “You must be born again” (John 3:7). Nicodemus was a good person by every external measure, and Jesus told him that his goodness was insufficient. He needed a new heart. He needed a work of God that he could not accomplish for himself.
The same is true for our children. We can raise children who are kind, honest, generous, and religiously observant. We can raise children who make us look like successful parents. But if they have never been born again, if the Holy Spirit has never awakened their dead hearts to the beauty of Christ, they are not godly. They are moral. And moralism is not Christianity; it is the enemy of Christianity because it inoculates children against the gospel. It teaches them that they do not need a Savior because they are already good enough.
This is the impossible task at the heart of parenting: we cannot regenerate our children. We cannot perform the new birth. We cannot breathe spiritual life into dead souls. Only the Spirit can do that.
Good Kids Are Not Godly Kids
Let me say it plainly, because it needs to be said: Your child’s good behavior is not evidence of godliness. It may be evidence of temperament, fear, or effective behavior modification. It may be evidence that they are compliant people-pleasers. It may be evidence that they have learned to perform Christianity convincingly.
This is not to say that godly children will not behave well. They will—increasingly and imperfectly—as the fruit of the Spirit grows. But the absence of behavioral problems is not the presence of godliness. And confusing the two is one of the most dangerous mistakes a parent can make.
I know parents who boasted of their children’s obedience, only to watch those same children walk away from the faith entirely the moment they left home. From the outside, no one saw it coming. The children were polite, respectful, active in youth groups, and morally clean. They were good kids. But they were not godly kids. They had learned to play the part, but their hearts had never been captured by Christ. And when the external structures of parental authority were removed, there was nothing internal to sustain them.
I have also known parents whose children went through seasons of visible rebellion—struggling with anger, with doubt, with poor choices—who today are passionate, humble, faithful followers of Jesus.
Those children, in their rebellion, were wrestling with the reality of faith in a way the “good kids” never did. The parents endured heartache and shame, but God was at work beneath the surface.
The point is not that rebellion is a sign of godliness, or that good behavior is a sign of hypocrisy. The point is that behavior is an unreliable indicator of the heart. We cannot look at our children’s external compliance and conclude that all is well. And we cannot look at their struggles and conclude that all is lost.
The question we must learn to ask—of ourselves and of our children—is not merely “What are you doing?” but “What do you love? Whom do you trust? What do you want?” The answers to those questions reveal the heart. And the heart is what God sees.
The Sovereignty of God in Parenting
If we cannot control the outcome, if we cannot regenerate our children’s hearts, what are we to do? The answer is found in the difficult but glorious doctrine of God’s sovereignty.
The Bible is clear that salvation belongs to the Lord (Psalm 3:8; Jonah 2:9; Revelation 7:10). From beginning to end, it is God who chooses, God who calls, God who regenerates, and same God who preserves. We do not add anything to the work of salvation except the faith that He Himself gives us. This is as true for our children as it is for anyone else.
For many parents, this is a source of deep anxiety. If salvation is up to God’s sovereign election, what if He has not chosen my child? What if I raise them in faith, pray for them fervently, and they are not among the elect?
This question reveals a misunderstanding of how the Bible presents God’s sovereignty. Scripture never presents the doctrine of election as a reason for despair or passivity. On the contrary, it is presented as a ground for confidence, hope, and perseverance. The same apostle who wrote, “He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world” (Ephesians 1:4) also wrote, “Bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord” (Ephesians 6:4). He saw no contradiction between God’s sovereignty and parental responsibility.
Here is the truth that sustains parents in the dark hours: God is more committed to the salvation of your children than you are. Your love for your child, fierce as it is, is but a dim reflection of His love. He knows your child more deeply than you ever will. He desires their salvation—not reluctantly, but passionately. And He has the power to accomplish what He desires.
This does not mean that every child of believing parents will be saved. We have all seen exceptions, and they are heartbreaking. But it does mean that we can entrust our children to a God who is good, who is powerful, and who loves them with an everlasting love. We can do what He calls us to do—train, teach, model, pray—and leave the results to Him.
This is not a resignation that leads to passivity. It is the confidence that leads to faithfulness. When we believe that the outcome depends ultimately on us, we parent with frantic anxiety, grasping for control, burning out in the effort. When we believe that the outcome depends ultimately on God, we parent with peaceful persistence, doing what He commands and trusting Him for the harvest.
The Necessity of the Holy Spirit
Zechariah 4:6 is one of the most important verses for the Christian parent to internalize: Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, says the Lord of hosts.
The context of this verse is illuminating. The people of Israel were attempting to rebuild the temple after the exile. The task was monumental; the opposition was fierce; and the resources were meager. Zerubbabel, the governor, must have felt the crushing weight of responsibility. And God’s word to him was this: you cannot accomplish this by your own strength or resources. This is My work, and it will be accomplished by My Spirit.
Parenting is a rebuilding project. You are building a soul, a disciple, a worshiper of God. The forces against you are formidable—the world, the flesh, and the devil. Your resources are meager—limited wisdom, limited patience, limited time. And God’s word to you is the same: you cannot accomplish this by your own might or power. This is His work, and it will be accomplished by His Spirit.
What does it mean to parent an individual by the Spirit? It means acknowledging your dependence on Him in prayer. It means asking for wisdom you do not have. It means waiting on the Spirit to convict your child’s heart when your words have failed. It means trusting that the Spirit is at work even when you see no evidence of it. It means believing that the same Spirit who raised Christ from the dead can bring life to your child’s dead heart.
Parenting by the Spirit also means recognizing that you are not the only agent in your child’s life. The Holy Spirit is the primary Disciple-Maker. Your job is to cooperate with what He is doing, not to replace Him. You are the assistant; He is the Master Teacher.
This is profoundly freeing. You do not have to manufacture conviction. You do not have to manipulate your child into faith. You do not have to carry the weight of their salvation. You are called to faithfulness, not to success. And the Spirit is faithful to work in ways you cannot see or measure.
The Fruit of Acknowledging the Impossible
When we truly embrace the impossibility of our task—when we stop pretending that we can produce godliness in our children by our own efforts—something shifts. The posture of our parenting changes in several significant ways.
First, we parent with humility. We stop looking down on parents whose children are struggling, because we recognize that we are not fundamentally different. We have no secret formula they lack. We have only been recipients of grace we did not earn. This humility makes us compassionate rather than judgmental, and it makes our homes places of grace rather than performance.
Second, we parent with prayer. When we believe the outcome depends on us, we pray as a last resort. When we believe the outcome depends on God, we pray as a first resort. Prayer becomes not the thing we do when everything else has failed, but the acknowledgment that everything else will fail without it. We pray over our children, with our children, and for our children with a desperation that reflects our true dependence.
Third, we parent with patience. When we are trying to control the outcome, every setback feels catastrophic. We demand immediate results. We push, pressure, and manipulate. But when we trust the timing of the Spirit, we can afford to be patient. We can plant seeds and wait for God to bring the harvest. We can allow our children to struggle and doubt and question, trusting that the Spirit uses even those seasons for their good.
Fourth, we parent with hope. The parent who believes everything depends on them is a parent living under the constant threat of failure. The parent who believes everything depends on God is a parent who can hope even in the darkest seasons. When your child is wandering, you do not despair, because you know that the Shepherd goes after wandering sheep. When your child is rebellious, you do not lose hope, because you have seen God break the hardest hearts. When your child seems indifferent, you do not give up, because you know that the Spirit can awaken the dead.
But Does Effort Matter?
At this point, a reader might reasonably ask: If the outcome depends entirely on God, why do anything? Why teach, why discipline, why model faith? Why not just pray and wait?
This objection misunderstands how God works. Throughout Scripture, God’s sovereignty never diminishes human responsibility; it establishes it. The same God who declares that salvation belongs to the Lord commands parents to train their children in the faith. The same God who gives the growth commands us to plant and water.
We do not work instead of God; we work in dependence on God. Our efforts are not the cause of our children’s salvation, but they are the means God uses to bring it about. We are not saviors, but we are instruments. And God delights to work through the ordinary, faithful obedience of parents.
Think of it this way: you cannot make a seed grow. The growth is a mystery, a miracle of God. But you can plant the seed. You can water it. You can pull the weeds. You can protect it from frost. And the farmer who does these things is not claiming to be the Creator; he is simply being a faithful steward of the Creator’s processes.
Parenting is like farming. You cannot make your child’s heart grow in godliness. That is the work of Holy Spirit. But you can plant the Word in their hearts. You can water it with prayer and teaching. You can pull the weeds of sinful influences. You can protect them from the frost of harmful relationships. And when you do these things in dependence on God, you are not trying to replace the Spirit; you are cooperating with Him.
The distinction between moralism and Spirit-dependent parenting is not that one puts in effort and the other does not. The distinction is in where the trust lies. The moralistic parent trusts in the effort itself. The Spirit-dependent parent trusts in the God who uses the effort. The actions may look similar from the outside, but the heart posture is entirely different—and that heart posture will determine whether the parent burns out or endures.
A Word to the Weary
If you are reading this chapter and feeling the weight of your inadequacy, I want to speak directly to you.
Perhaps you are the parent of a prodigal. You did everything you knew you had to do. You raised them in the church, prayed over them every night, taught them Scripture, and now they want nothing to do with God.
You are tempted to believe that their rejection of faith reflects your failure. You carry a guilt that is slowly crushing you.
Let me release you from a burden you were never meant to carry. You did not fail, because the outcome was never yours to secure. You were faithful. You planted and watered. The growth—or the apparent lack of it—is in God’s hands. Do not let the enemy use your child’s choices to convince you that you are a failure. You are a steward, not a savior. And stewards are judged on faithfulness, not outcomes.
Perhaps you are the parent of young children, and you are terrified. You look at the world your children are growing up in—the cultural hostility to faith, the pervasive technology, the moral confusion—and you wonder how anyone could raise godly children in such an environment. The task feels impossible because it is impossible. And that is exactly where God wants you: at the end of yourself, looking to Him.
Perhaps you are the parent who has tried everything. You have read the books, attended the conferences, implemented the systems, and still your children struggle. You are exhausted. You have nothing left to try. Good. That is the place where God’s power meets our weakness. When you stop trying to be sufficient, you become a vessel for the One who is.
The Foundation Laid
This chapter has been about laying the foundation for everything that follows. Before we talk about family worship, discipline, technology, or any of the practical matters of parenting, we had to settle this: You cannot raise godly children. Only God can.
This is not a counsel of despair; it is a counsel of liberation. The burden of saving your children was never meant to be yours. It belongs to the One who spoke the universe into existence, who raised Christ from the dead, who calls dead hearts to life. And He is not tired. He is never overwhelmed. He is not failing.
Your task is faithfulness and dependence. Your task is to plant, water, teach, model, pray, and trust. The growth is His.
Zechariah 4:6 is not just a verse about rebuilding a temple; it is a verse for every parent who has ever knelt beside a child’s bed, wondering if their prayers are making any difference. “Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, says the Lord of hosts.”
The Spirit who hovered over the face of the waters at creation, bringing order out of chaos, hovers over your home. The Spirit who overshadowed Mary and brought forth the Savior can bring forth new life in your children. The Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead is not stymied by your inadequacy, your mistakes, or your children’s rebellion.
You are not enough for this task. You were never meant to be.
But God is. And He is with you.
Questions for Reflection
1. In what areas of your parenting do you find yourself most tempted to rely on your own “might and power” rather than the Spirit?
2. Can you identify ways you may have inadvertently trained your children in moralism rather than godliness? What might it look like to shift that emphasis?
3. How does the doctrine of God’s sovereignty affect your parenting? Does it bring you anxiety or peace? Why?
4. What would change in your parenting if you truly believed that the Holy Spirit is the primary Disciple-Maker and you are His assistant?
5. Are there burdens you are carrying that belong to God? What would it look like to release them to Him?
Prayer for the Journey
Father, I confess that I have often parented as if everything depended on me. I have carried weights You never asked me to bear. I have judged myself by outcomes You never promised to give me. Forgive me for my self-reliance and teach me to depend on Your Spirit.
I acknowledge that I cannot raise godly children. I cannot change their hearts. I cannot secure their salvation. This task is impossible—for me. But nothing is impossible for You.
Holy Spirit, I ask You to do what I cannot do. Breathe life into my children’s hearts. Capture their affections with the beauty of Christ. Convict them of sin, lead them to repentance, and sustain them in faith. Make them godly—not just well-behaved, not just religious, but genuinely, deeply, passionately Yours.
And while You work in them, work in me. Make me humble, faithful, and dependent. I release my children into Your hands. They were always Yours more than mine. In Jesus’ name, Amen.
Get a copy now
Leave a Reply