All over the world, good health outcomes are achieved through good, innovative leadership and by establishing robust governance mechanisms (Fullman et al., 2017). Therefore, stakeholders in the Nigerian health sector have a responsibility to collaborate towards enacting and implementing digital health strategy and regulations. Considering the importance of governance in scaling digital health (Ngoc et al., 2018), stakeholders should prioritize creating sustainable governance mechanisms by inaugurating committees for strategic decision-making such as:
- Technical Working Groups (TWGs) that can provide technical support, and
- Program Management Office that will be responsible for implementing all approved strategies and decisions.
Basically, digital health governance mechanism in Nigeria should be categorized into three vis-a-vis: (i) Health ministry mechanism purposely established to drive digital health as well as mobilize technical capacity and skills from various agencies, companies, organizations and line-ministries in order to successfully deploy DH systems across the country (ii) Government-wide digital mechanism created to develop a strong and vibrant internet communication technology (ICT) infrastructure and capacity, and (iii) Digital health agency mechanism for driving the implementation of digital health strategy and solution.
The roles of DH governance in Nigeria include: (a) stakeholder engagement (b) program management (c) strategic architecture (d) clinical safety, management and operations (e) monitoring and evaluation, and (f) policy oversight, among others (Ebenso et al., 2017). Using the government-wide digital model found in Estonia, it becomes easy to elaborate on the basic concepts of DH governance and explain how DH governance structures can be effectively and efficiently operationalized. For example, the Estonian framework highlights the huge gains of a digital health approach based on a comprehensive e-Government model that integrates some fundamental structural elements—such as a functional and up-to-date national electronic identification database, and a country-specific system architecture specially designed for interoperability. Some African countries that have modified and integrated the Estonian DH model as well as improved their health systems include Rwanda, Zambia and South Africa. Facilitators and participants at the 2019 DH capacity development workshop held from 20 – 30 November in Abuja and across the six geo-political zones of Nigeria shared their experiences and success stories from the programme. They all agreed on the effectiveness of an integrated approach to DH governance, with highlight on how the various state governments spearheaded all digital health narratives to achieve good health outcomes. Using Ondo state and its resilient experience in the DH programme as a case study, key lessons include the following:
- Collaborate with programme partners and vendors to ensure they use the same applications
- Partner with all vendors to identify and fill gaps on time
- Unite and agree with stakeholders to regularly brainstorm and find the most effective strategies that can address system challenges
- Coordinate support from key stakeholders, policymakers and the government.
The crucial role of government in DH, especially in scaling DH infrastructure/technologies, cannot be over-emphasized (Simmons et al., 2007). Thus, the Nigerian government has to be fully involved and committed to developing and deploying digital health strategies and simultaneously providing robust leadership which should be evident in how the DH ecosystem is regulated. An innovative leadership is crucial in Nigeria due to the fragmented nature of health system. Additionally, DH strategy serves as a roadmap for planning, developing and coordinating various DH initiatives in every country. Therefore, stakeholders in Nigeria’s DH ecosystem should understand that any chosen strategy toolkit has to correctly identify changes (including action plans, desired outcomes and governance mechanisms) that the health system need to gain vibrancy, multi-sectoral collaboration, interoperability and sustainability. In line with the International Telecommunication Union (ITU)-WHO National e-Health strategy toolkit formulated with the WHA71 resolutions on digital health and related areas, every country-specific strategy should highlight the following:
- Transfer of technology and knowledge
- Promoting integrated people-centred health services
- Recycling and adaptations
- Interoperability
- Digital technology integration into existing health systems’ infrastructure, and
- Implementations and scale up through DH strategies.
More areas in need of attention are digital health regulations and policies, and more specifically, how these can be aligned with international standards. DH regulations and policies in Nigeria should be acceptable, culturally adaptable and easily accessible. However, the necessity and benefits of using systems thinking approach to engage stakeholders in DH governance and regulatory dialogues cannot be overemphasized (Mangham et al., 2010) because establishing a national digital health strategy is not enough. To achieve good health outcomes through DH transformation, Nigeria should aim beyond having a national DH strategy to DH interventions identification and requirement analysis, up to the application design, development, deployment as well as monitoring and evaluation of digital health interventions. Some of the major research themes on the adoption of digital health infrastructure are:
- DH governance mechanisms
- Internal capacity building, and
- Technical requirement gathering for systems.
It is pertinent to add that while innovative leadership and effective governance play major roles in scaling digital health technologies, all state governments in Nigeria have a responsibility to create a conducive atmosphere for the smooth implementation of DH strategies (Labrique et al., 2018). In addition, it is necessary to institutionalize some effective regulatory and financial mechanisms as well as collaborate with stakeholders in the DH ecosystem to develop and implement cost-effective, scalable and recyclable digital health initiatives according to local contexts. With full support from WHO and FMoH, the federal government should also provide financial and technical support for states that do not have existing digital health structures.

Leave a Reply