A Financial Times commentary argues that among the G7 economies, France and the United States are “heading into a wall” on public finances, with both on track to exceed Japan’s net debt ratio by 2031.
Writing for the Financial Times, Chris Giles assesses which G7 economy deserves the title of “poster child for debt woes” following the IMF’s annual meetings, where managing director Kristalina Georgieva issued a blunt warning: “Make urgent repairs to the fiscal house before the cracks widen.”
The message was aimed squarely at G7 countries too large for IMF rescue financing. Yet apart from US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who did not attend the Bangkok meetings, most finance ministers nodded along while pointing to domestic deficit-reduction forecasts—without committing to immediate action.
A Poor Record of Fiscal Repair
The commentary notes that public finances can run on unsustainable paths for a long time before anything breaks, and the G7’s track record is worse than Georgieva suggested. Over the past decade, the IMF has repeatedly revised its G7 deficit expectations upward. Before the pandemic, the fund generally expected deficits to settle around 2.5 per cent of GDP; this month’s forecasts predict stability at over 6 per cent—a level that puts debt on an ever-rising path and will eventually force at least one G7 country into crisis.
Canada and Germany are ruled out as candidates for a market rout, given their low debt and histories of prudence. Germany’s recent deficit increases to fund defence and investment were justified, the piece argues, since such spending should never have been cut so hard. Japan is also tentatively excluded: despite having the G7’s second-highest net debt ratio in 2026, it has consistently run smaller deficits than forecast, with its finance ministry keeping a tight grip on the reins even as Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi talks up fiscal expansion.
Italy, despite one of the highest net debt levels in the G7, ran persistent primary surpluses after the 2010–2015 Eurozone crisis and has a stable debt ratio—not a recipe for crisis. The UK, meanwhile, was perhaps excessively praised by the IMF for its consolidation plans; next week’s Budget is likely to show slippage, and Britain has “a nasty habit of being an unreliable boyfriend on the deficit, always promising probity without delivering it.”
Heading Into a Wall
That leaves France and the US. Both have records of promising lower deficits that never materialise, alongside high deficits and rapidly rising debt. On the IMF’s latest forecasts, both will exceed Japan’s net debt ratio by 2031—and only Japan has a history of beating IMF predictions.
Politics in both countries is hostile to the reforms needed. In France, far-right leader Marine Le Pen speaks of responsibility but opposes the pension age reform central to healthier public finances, while more centrist politicians cannot pass a budget. In the US, neither party sees electoral benefit in fiscal prudence.
The IMF was careful to call reform urgent rather than predict imminent disaster. But as the commentary observes, fiscal problems resemble demographics: extremely easy to predict, apart from the moment the dam breaks. Among the G7, France and the US are heading into a wall—and the consequences will be ugly. We just do not know which country will crash first.

Leave a Reply