The speculation around the chancellor’s budget this autumn has been “extraordinary”, a “shambles” and is “really damaging”, a senior economist has warned.
Paul Johnson has hit out at Rachel Reeves and the way information about her budget on Wednesday has saturated the media.
Johnson, who was the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), was speaking to Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips.
Asked about speculation around the budget, he said: “I mean, it’s been extraordinary. I can’t believe we’re still waiting. It’s been 5 or 6 months of speculation.
“But it’s not been trailed in the way that many budgets are trailed. I mean, many budgets have been trailed in the sense that we’ve got a drip-drip of what’s actually going to happen.
“We’ve had months and months of speculation about this might happen, that might happen, virtually everything might happen. And then, of course, we have the extraordinary U-turn on the U-turn with regard to the manifesto commitments.”
This is a reference to the decision that the chancellor would not be hiking income tax, despite it all but being spelled out that this would happen.
It is thought this change of policy came at the last minute as Sir Keir Starmer and Reeves feared doing so – a breach of Labour’s manifesto commitments – could lead to open rebellion from some of their own MPs.
Johnson continued: “This is genuinely damaging.
“I mean, the Bank of England, in its latest report, the very first thing it said about the reason for slow growth in the last few months is speculation about the budget.
“So this has been really poorly, really poorly handled. And I mean, at least we’ll find out the answer in a couple of days.”
Asked to sum up the whole process in a single word, he responded: “Not one I think I can repeat on morning television. ‘Shambles’ will be a good one.”
He also suggested that speculation could have harmed both business investment and the housing market.
He said: “All of this has actual real world damaging effects on the economy because of the degree of uncertainty and speculation, which itself is wrapped up in where we were last year with no room against the fiscal rules.”

Leave a Reply