Is Pique really important to Barcelona’s title dreams?

The elephant in the room at Barcelona brings shivers to supporters when brought up–that’s exactly what happens with Lionel Messi’s presence in the squad. But what do we expect after Lionel Messi?

Messi is not the only generational player. Barcelona will have to think out of the box, and beyond the Argentina international player, in the coming years. This reminds us of another equally charismatic Barcelona player, Gerard Pique.

Pique’s contribution to Barca’s success since he rejoined from Manchester United in 2008 has been huge. And his importance to the team, as has once again been magnified in the last few weeks, remains equally as big.

The defender often spends the first half of the season in the spotlight for the wrong reasons. In February, he turned 33 and for the last few years there have been questions about whether he is physically up to the task. This season, with his focus drifting when organising the Davis Cup, his commitment was also up for the debate.

A league game at Getafe, a club handily based in Madrid, where the Davis Cup took place, allowed him to mix football and business in November. It created a lot of discussion about whether Pique’s heart is still in the game.

It has since been revealed that one of the social media accounts ran by I3 Ventures — a third-party company that until recently worked with Barca — had heavily criticised Pique at the time. Barca have subsequently denied they were aware of posts made by I3 amid allegations they were behind campaigns to smear various people related to the club.

Ernesto Valverde, the coach at the time, even suggested he would have to think about whether Pique would start at Getafe following a week of toing and froing between Barcelona and Madrid to follow the Davis Cup.

Valverde, though, could never have dropped Pique. He is far too important and the team is far too reliant on him.

If that isn’t always completely true in the early days of a season, when at times his performances have fluctuated, it is when the games that really matter arrive.

Pique has a habit of turning up on the big occasions. He has excelled in recent weeks against Napoli, Real Madrid and Real Sociedad. Against Napoli he led the team from defence, completing 114 of 120 passes. Barca lacked creativity further forward. Against Madrid he dealt with almost everything chucked at him, making a game-high six clearances and three interceptions. He was extremely unfortunate to deflect home Vinicius’ opener. Against La Real, he was also one of Barca’s best performers.

Off the pitch, his discourse has been very on-task, too. That isn’t always the case. Before the Napoli game, he didn’t take the chance to criticise the board or president Josep Maria Bartomeu for the relationship with I3 — although he didn’t miss the opportunity to point out that the players, through “sustained success,” have prevented the club spiraling into total crisis mode in recent years.

After the La Real game, he also played down the Eder Sarabia controversy. Quique Setien’s No.2 had been called out for his touchline behaviour during the Clasico. Pique said it was normal and that the players were not annoyed.

He will be a difficult man to replace when he’s gone but he will be impossible to replace if they lose him to injury this season. He has managed to stay fit this season, fighting off some minor knocks, but is beginning to tire. Before one goal kick at the weekend, he told goalkeeper Marc-Andre ter Stegen to take his time and play it long. The aim was for Barca to waste some time and get their breath back.

Pique’s played 25 out of 27 league games this season. The two he’s missed have been due to suspension. In the Champions League, he’s played five out of seven. He missed one through suspension and was rested against Inter, with top spot in the group sewn up.

Without him, Barca would go with two lefties — Samuel Umtiti and Clement Lenglet — while B team defender Ronald Araujo has emerged as the fourth choice centre-back following Jean-Clair Todibo’s January move. But as good as those three may be, going without Pique is something the Blaugrana don’t even want to consider.